Post by Bethany Joy Galeotti on Feb 22, 2012 7:32:10 GMT -5
Hello Girls!!!
Let's start our judging session now!!!
Beth: I get the 'peace' vibe here. I think you look amazing here. The concept is unique and also different. You stand out here. The quality of the photo itself is good. My only comment, hmm I think this photo would be better if you pick Environmental Issue as your issue this week. Other than that, it's a good photo
Anna: Stunning as usual I see, Ayumi. I really like your interpretation of "anti-war" here. In most cases when it comes to this issue, it seems models tend to go the "fragile and innocent" route, but you look like a strong and proud Amazon Princess (of the peaceful variety of course), which I think is fantastic. Your pose and expression work great for this, and your "leaf outfit" matches the theme (though a bit tacky in my opinion). Once again, the lighting is a bit harsh, but it doesn't distract from you so I'm fine with it. Overall, I can clearly understand the theme (the dove is even a nice touch for emphasizing the whole idea of "peace") and you look great, so I think you've done an all around great job.
Amanda: I'm shocked that people were against going to Afghanistan. I don't get how anyone could be that stupid. If a country gets attacked, they get to go blow the brains out of their attackers... along with anyone who protects them. You have to remember... there is no such thing as "world peace." Evil is always looking to get ahead. That's why Afghanistan had to happen: To stop it.
Despite that, you portray this well. I didn't get the same vibe as Anna did - I am seriously feeling Genesis here. Eve, the Garden of Eden, possibly just having been kicked out and having to start afresh upon realizing that there were demons in the world. I really understand this photo a lot. You look peaceful and serene, though yeah, the lighting is a bit... problematic. And the outfit is a bit too... "natural" for me. Regardless, you really do look amazing, and you should expect a lot of points from me
Joan: I think the pose and facial expression is very strong. You look motivated to stop war and bring peace all around you. I like the concept a lot, and the addition to the bird on your shoulder is a good touch. You also do look stunning here, it is an impressive photo. I do agree people can get confused that this photo could be about natural but I still see the “anti-war” element here. Good job!
Beth: I don't understand your explanation, girl. Once again you came across as safe for me. You do look great but as for the connection with your issue, I can't feel it
Anna: Unfortunately Charlize, I think you've completely missed the mark on your political issue. I mean really, if you are trying to represent the "wealthy 1%", why can't you afford to buy an outfit? Yes, I see the fancy watch, but that is literally the only thing in this photo that shows us wealth. Also, if you are trying to illustrate the problems with our failing economy, I find it odd that you have chosen to represent the rich...so, you are in support of the wealthy 1%? Aside from all of the theme nonsense, I do think you look gorgeous (though I'm not a big fan of your eyes for the first time ever), and your pose really is sophisticated, yet has an edge of sexiness. However, last week, we complained about how boring your photo was, and once again you are giving us a simple studio shot (with distracting text to boot). I'm sorry my dear, but this is quite a bad week for you.
Amanda: I completely understand what you're trying to go for here, Charlize... but I really don't see you attaining it. I don't see "upper class" at all. I don't really get much of any kind of "political" vibe from this. Unless this is a political ad and you're a former stripper or something, since you're only wearing a suitor's good jacket. That's my biggest issue - you're not wearing anything of your own. And I too am iffy on your expression. You look... almost bewildered, almost mortified. You're not giving us any satisfaction or power. It's not in line with your description, and... it's really weak. Sorry Charlize, but you're running out of steam. :/
Joan: I do understand what you were going here as well. I think you were very creative and this is a nice effort from you. Certainly not you’re best but not you’re worst either. Honestly though you look more like a tramp rather than wealthy 1%, you do look gorgeous here, but when do you ever not look gorgeous? Well that movie Monster but still!
Beth: Hmmm... I think you were being too analytical here. Not sure if people can relate your photo to Gay Marriage. But that's not my biggest problem. My biggest issue is your face here. The angle wasn't good. I'm a fan of profile shoot but this photo didn't work for me. But the styling is beautiful.
Anna: I agree with Beth here; I can see how much thought you've put into this, but your photo is essentially supposed to speak for itself, and unless we happen to be Sherlock Holmes, I doubt very many people would put all of your subtle clues (consisting of the color purple, portraits of women, arms reaching into the shot, and a wedding dress) together to fully understand your message. I also think it's rather odd that your tailors and stylists are supposed to be representing the government here, hehe. Anywho, I am impressed that you decided to stay away from the cliches in this issue, and have gone a more creative route, I'm just afraid people wouldn't grasp the "gay marriage" theme without reading your wonderful essay first. As far as you specifically, I think you look exquisite. The dress looks great, the accessories compliment you without being overbearing, and I think your pose is lovely.
Amanda: This represents marriage wonderfully, and by definition, "marriage" is a union between a man and a woman in which they come together to start a family. You may have "subtle" clues that you're trying to "marry" a woman, but I don't follow them. Plus, that goes against the definition of marriage - civil unions are to have equal rights to marriage, but they just aren't marriage. Call me a traditionalist all you want, but that's the way it is.
And that's why your idea falls pretty flat here, Emmy. You do look beautiful, but I must agree with Beth - you're not modeling this dress, You're preparing for a wedding. this may very well be a shot from your wedding with your ex-husband. I don't get the vibe that it's a photoshoot. All you have going for you is that you look great. Nothing else. You picked the wrong issue, really, since it's hard to convey... sorry :/
Joan: This is definitely a photo where your explanation helps a lot. Gay marriage would never come to mind here, by just looking at this photo, just a beautiful girl getting ready to get married. Reading your explanation and looking at this photo longer, I kind of see the gay marriage aspect but it is not a moving photo, or inspirational which what I expected. This photo is just basic, and the angle of your face is horrible. I like the natural feel to this photo but like Amanda said model the dress.
Beth: Simply gorgeous. I love this photo Gwen. I think you manage to combine your issue with fashion really well. The fashion element here is strong and the setting is amazing. Well done, Gwen
Anna: This really is spectacular, Gwen. The lighting and setting are gorgeous, and your chosen issue is crystal clear. I love your pose and styling as well; your outfit is perfect, your hair is unique, and I think it's wonderful how your nails and lips are the only red things in the shot...it really helps draw the focus up to your face. The handcuffs are a nice touch, and are almost fancy enough to be considered a fashion accessory. However, I'm not completely satisfied with your expression...your eyes look great, but I think it's your mouth and chin that bothers me, I'm not exactly sure.
Amanda: I wasn't expecting this. You nailed the theme, and you took an old-fashioned prison uniform and made it... high fashion? Wow. The setting is great. I love the handcuffs. Your styling is impeccable - I don't really like the hair, but with this setting, it actually works nicely. However, I must agree with Anna about your expression - it almost seems like you're seducing a guard, and that sort of detracts from the theme. You want to get out, yes, but is that really the way to do it today? This is more of a reflection of the past than it is of modernity, I think - but that doesn't change that this very well could be your best photo yet.
Joan: Wow! I also was not expecting this at all! Not only did you nail your theme, you also look stunning. Actually this whole photo is stunning. I love everything about this photo and have no complaints at all! The pose, strong face, the setting. It all fits together for your theme but you also do not look like a bum. You look like a model! I am so happy and proud!
Beth: This photo reminds me of Shilpa's photo last cycle. I think you did great Katy. The costumes are beautiful. I think you can work on your posture more. But overall, you executed the theme well. I can feel your love towards the animal and it's definitely anti-fur.
Anna: My goodness, I've been calling you plastic for so long, it looks like you decided to just go all out and wear an entire plastic outfit...interesting. As far as your political issue goes, you've done a nice job of portraying it (though I personally think fur is divine, and I'm wearing it as we speak). I also like the setting; I'm glad you were able to come up with something more interesting than just a solid screen behind you. Unfortunately, that's where the goodness ends. I think your pose is incredibly awkward (I swear if you poop on the floor I'm going to make you clean it up), and your expression is...well, let's just say it's not working. I also can't help but notice those pads under your knees, are they there so you don't go flying across the floor like a fat kid on a slip 'n slide? Okay, I've rambled on for quite long enough; to summarize, you've done a nice job with the theme, but your pose and expression fall short.
Amanda: I am with Anna. You're wearing a plastic catsuit. Plastic. After Anna has been on your case for so long. Look what happened to Miley - she got the boot for not taking our feedback. Also, your expression is almost evil. Mix that with a white cat, and...
I can't stand that tail, as it's creepy. I'm not a fur person myself (organic foods are tasty though), but this is going too far. I DO like the setting and the idea, it's just that the execution is falling flat. And when you pick Anti-fur, you have Shilpa's amazing photo last cycle to live up to. Shilpa didn't wear a plastic pink-and-blue catsuit. No, Shilpa tried to look like an imprisoned Bengal Tiger going to be skinned. I also don't think she wore heels, and she didn't need those tacky pads which should have been Photoshopped out of there. So yeah... all you have going for you is your idea, and that's not enough to impress me... or Anna for that matter. Sorry Katy :/
Joan: So instead of wearing fur of a cheetah, you’re wearing a rubber outfit of a cheetah print! I love that! Also you holding the cat just helps represent your politic issue. I like this photo and think you did a good job at getting your issue correctly. But I do think your facial expression is more naughty rather than please don’t wear fur. But then again you’re in a skimpy cat woman costume.
Beth: I like it. I think it's very cute and sexy. I think your issue was addressed properly here. I like the whole concept. Good job, Sarah. One thing, that I can advice you is to work on your legs here. Your legs pose made you look shorter. But overall for me, you did great, Sarah.
Anna: YOU CAN WALK! Sarah, you've done a nice job this week. You have portrayed your political issue wonderfully, and you haven't sacrificed your beauty in the process. I must admit this does have a bit of a cheesy "Halloween" vibe, but the setting helps to keep things grounded. Your pose and expression are pretty simple here, but you do look nice and it works. Overall, I'm happy with how you have chosen to illustrate a very serious issue in a lighthearted and creative way; nicely done.
Amanda: I don't know if I like this. I am happy that your hip surgery was a success and you can walk again, but this...? It's kind of cheesy, all right, and it doesn't strike me as high-fashion. I do see it as a costume of sorts, as it's not the kind of thing a typical nurse wears these days. It's almost dated... even before the 90s dated, I mean. I do like the setting, and you do portray your issue well, so that alone is good enough for me! Well done
Joan: I think every guy would love for you to be their nurse right now! Even though you did get your politic issue correct, you look like a catalog model rather than model. The pose is like “ooo look at me!” I also do think this is a bit cheesy and over the top. But still not a bad photo at all, you did a good job Sarah!
Anne failed to submit her photo
Let's start our judging session now!!!
Beth: I get the 'peace' vibe here. I think you look amazing here. The concept is unique and also different. You stand out here. The quality of the photo itself is good. My only comment, hmm I think this photo would be better if you pick Environmental Issue as your issue this week. Other than that, it's a good photo
Anna: Stunning as usual I see, Ayumi. I really like your interpretation of "anti-war" here. In most cases when it comes to this issue, it seems models tend to go the "fragile and innocent" route, but you look like a strong and proud Amazon Princess (of the peaceful variety of course), which I think is fantastic. Your pose and expression work great for this, and your "leaf outfit" matches the theme (though a bit tacky in my opinion). Once again, the lighting is a bit harsh, but it doesn't distract from you so I'm fine with it. Overall, I can clearly understand the theme (the dove is even a nice touch for emphasizing the whole idea of "peace") and you look great, so I think you've done an all around great job.
Amanda: I'm shocked that people were against going to Afghanistan. I don't get how anyone could be that stupid. If a country gets attacked, they get to go blow the brains out of their attackers... along with anyone who protects them. You have to remember... there is no such thing as "world peace." Evil is always looking to get ahead. That's why Afghanistan had to happen: To stop it.
Despite that, you portray this well. I didn't get the same vibe as Anna did - I am seriously feeling Genesis here. Eve, the Garden of Eden, possibly just having been kicked out and having to start afresh upon realizing that there were demons in the world. I really understand this photo a lot. You look peaceful and serene, though yeah, the lighting is a bit... problematic. And the outfit is a bit too... "natural" for me. Regardless, you really do look amazing, and you should expect a lot of points from me
Joan: I think the pose and facial expression is very strong. You look motivated to stop war and bring peace all around you. I like the concept a lot, and the addition to the bird on your shoulder is a good touch. You also do look stunning here, it is an impressive photo. I do agree people can get confused that this photo could be about natural but I still see the “anti-war” element here. Good job!
Beth: I don't understand your explanation, girl. Once again you came across as safe for me. You do look great but as for the connection with your issue, I can't feel it
Anna: Unfortunately Charlize, I think you've completely missed the mark on your political issue. I mean really, if you are trying to represent the "wealthy 1%", why can't you afford to buy an outfit? Yes, I see the fancy watch, but that is literally the only thing in this photo that shows us wealth. Also, if you are trying to illustrate the problems with our failing economy, I find it odd that you have chosen to represent the rich...so, you are in support of the wealthy 1%? Aside from all of the theme nonsense, I do think you look gorgeous (though I'm not a big fan of your eyes for the first time ever), and your pose really is sophisticated, yet has an edge of sexiness. However, last week, we complained about how boring your photo was, and once again you are giving us a simple studio shot (with distracting text to boot). I'm sorry my dear, but this is quite a bad week for you.
Amanda: I completely understand what you're trying to go for here, Charlize... but I really don't see you attaining it. I don't see "upper class" at all. I don't really get much of any kind of "political" vibe from this. Unless this is a political ad and you're a former stripper or something, since you're only wearing a suitor's good jacket. That's my biggest issue - you're not wearing anything of your own. And I too am iffy on your expression. You look... almost bewildered, almost mortified. You're not giving us any satisfaction or power. It's not in line with your description, and... it's really weak. Sorry Charlize, but you're running out of steam. :/
Joan: I do understand what you were going here as well. I think you were very creative and this is a nice effort from you. Certainly not you’re best but not you’re worst either. Honestly though you look more like a tramp rather than wealthy 1%, you do look gorgeous here, but when do you ever not look gorgeous? Well that movie Monster but still!
Beth: Hmmm... I think you were being too analytical here. Not sure if people can relate your photo to Gay Marriage. But that's not my biggest problem. My biggest issue is your face here. The angle wasn't good. I'm a fan of profile shoot but this photo didn't work for me. But the styling is beautiful.
Anna: I agree with Beth here; I can see how much thought you've put into this, but your photo is essentially supposed to speak for itself, and unless we happen to be Sherlock Holmes, I doubt very many people would put all of your subtle clues (consisting of the color purple, portraits of women, arms reaching into the shot, and a wedding dress) together to fully understand your message. I also think it's rather odd that your tailors and stylists are supposed to be representing the government here, hehe. Anywho, I am impressed that you decided to stay away from the cliches in this issue, and have gone a more creative route, I'm just afraid people wouldn't grasp the "gay marriage" theme without reading your wonderful essay first. As far as you specifically, I think you look exquisite. The dress looks great, the accessories compliment you without being overbearing, and I think your pose is lovely.
Amanda: This represents marriage wonderfully, and by definition, "marriage" is a union between a man and a woman in which they come together to start a family. You may have "subtle" clues that you're trying to "marry" a woman, but I don't follow them. Plus, that goes against the definition of marriage - civil unions are to have equal rights to marriage, but they just aren't marriage. Call me a traditionalist all you want, but that's the way it is.
And that's why your idea falls pretty flat here, Emmy. You do look beautiful, but I must agree with Beth - you're not modeling this dress, You're preparing for a wedding. this may very well be a shot from your wedding with your ex-husband. I don't get the vibe that it's a photoshoot. All you have going for you is that you look great. Nothing else. You picked the wrong issue, really, since it's hard to convey... sorry :/
Joan: This is definitely a photo where your explanation helps a lot. Gay marriage would never come to mind here, by just looking at this photo, just a beautiful girl getting ready to get married. Reading your explanation and looking at this photo longer, I kind of see the gay marriage aspect but it is not a moving photo, or inspirational which what I expected. This photo is just basic, and the angle of your face is horrible. I like the natural feel to this photo but like Amanda said model the dress.
Beth: Simply gorgeous. I love this photo Gwen. I think you manage to combine your issue with fashion really well. The fashion element here is strong and the setting is amazing. Well done, Gwen
Anna: This really is spectacular, Gwen. The lighting and setting are gorgeous, and your chosen issue is crystal clear. I love your pose and styling as well; your outfit is perfect, your hair is unique, and I think it's wonderful how your nails and lips are the only red things in the shot...it really helps draw the focus up to your face. The handcuffs are a nice touch, and are almost fancy enough to be considered a fashion accessory. However, I'm not completely satisfied with your expression...your eyes look great, but I think it's your mouth and chin that bothers me, I'm not exactly sure.
Amanda: I wasn't expecting this. You nailed the theme, and you took an old-fashioned prison uniform and made it... high fashion? Wow. The setting is great. I love the handcuffs. Your styling is impeccable - I don't really like the hair, but with this setting, it actually works nicely. However, I must agree with Anna about your expression - it almost seems like you're seducing a guard, and that sort of detracts from the theme. You want to get out, yes, but is that really the way to do it today? This is more of a reflection of the past than it is of modernity, I think - but that doesn't change that this very well could be your best photo yet.
Joan: Wow! I also was not expecting this at all! Not only did you nail your theme, you also look stunning. Actually this whole photo is stunning. I love everything about this photo and have no complaints at all! The pose, strong face, the setting. It all fits together for your theme but you also do not look like a bum. You look like a model! I am so happy and proud!
Beth: This photo reminds me of Shilpa's photo last cycle. I think you did great Katy. The costumes are beautiful. I think you can work on your posture more. But overall, you executed the theme well. I can feel your love towards the animal and it's definitely anti-fur.
Anna: My goodness, I've been calling you plastic for so long, it looks like you decided to just go all out and wear an entire plastic outfit...interesting. As far as your political issue goes, you've done a nice job of portraying it (though I personally think fur is divine, and I'm wearing it as we speak). I also like the setting; I'm glad you were able to come up with something more interesting than just a solid screen behind you. Unfortunately, that's where the goodness ends. I think your pose is incredibly awkward (I swear if you poop on the floor I'm going to make you clean it up), and your expression is...well, let's just say it's not working. I also can't help but notice those pads under your knees, are they there so you don't go flying across the floor like a fat kid on a slip 'n slide? Okay, I've rambled on for quite long enough; to summarize, you've done a nice job with the theme, but your pose and expression fall short.
Amanda: I am with Anna. You're wearing a plastic catsuit. Plastic. After Anna has been on your case for so long. Look what happened to Miley - she got the boot for not taking our feedback. Also, your expression is almost evil. Mix that with a white cat, and...
I can't stand that tail, as it's creepy. I'm not a fur person myself (organic foods are tasty though), but this is going too far. I DO like the setting and the idea, it's just that the execution is falling flat. And when you pick Anti-fur, you have Shilpa's amazing photo last cycle to live up to. Shilpa didn't wear a plastic pink-and-blue catsuit. No, Shilpa tried to look like an imprisoned Bengal Tiger going to be skinned. I also don't think she wore heels, and she didn't need those tacky pads which should have been Photoshopped out of there. So yeah... all you have going for you is your idea, and that's not enough to impress me... or Anna for that matter. Sorry Katy :/
Joan: So instead of wearing fur of a cheetah, you’re wearing a rubber outfit of a cheetah print! I love that! Also you holding the cat just helps represent your politic issue. I like this photo and think you did a good job at getting your issue correctly. But I do think your facial expression is more naughty rather than please don’t wear fur. But then again you’re in a skimpy cat woman costume.
Beth: I like it. I think it's very cute and sexy. I think your issue was addressed properly here. I like the whole concept. Good job, Sarah. One thing, that I can advice you is to work on your legs here. Your legs pose made you look shorter. But overall for me, you did great, Sarah.
Anna: YOU CAN WALK! Sarah, you've done a nice job this week. You have portrayed your political issue wonderfully, and you haven't sacrificed your beauty in the process. I must admit this does have a bit of a cheesy "Halloween" vibe, but the setting helps to keep things grounded. Your pose and expression are pretty simple here, but you do look nice and it works. Overall, I'm happy with how you have chosen to illustrate a very serious issue in a lighthearted and creative way; nicely done.
Amanda: I don't know if I like this. I am happy that your hip surgery was a success and you can walk again, but this...? It's kind of cheesy, all right, and it doesn't strike me as high-fashion. I do see it as a costume of sorts, as it's not the kind of thing a typical nurse wears these days. It's almost dated... even before the 90s dated, I mean. I do like the setting, and you do portray your issue well, so that alone is good enough for me! Well done
Joan: I think every guy would love for you to be their nurse right now! Even though you did get your politic issue correct, you look like a catalog model rather than model. The pose is like “ooo look at me!” I also do think this is a bit cheesy and over the top. But still not a bad photo at all, you did a good job Sarah!
Anne failed to submit her photo
